Showing posts with label Six Nations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Six Nations. Show all posts

Heineken Cup weekend offers calm before the storm

Bath v Stade Francais

Julien Dupuy's Stade Français look set to keep flying high in the Heineken Cup. Photograph: David Davies/PA

It's not often that a round of the Heineken Cup fails to stir the juices, but you can tell that round five is a little flat by the heavy promotion of the route for three pool runners-up into the Amlin Cup. While the two best second-placed teams – see how convoluted this can become – will go on their travels to away quarter-finals in the main tournament, the next best three runners-up will go into the last eight of the Amlin and one pool runner-up will wave goodbye to Europe for the season. It's not exactly the most compelling of sales pitches.

It's not that the Heineken Cup has gone completely off the boil. It's just that round five is the calm before six, the showdown round with everything at stake. Munster-Northampton, Ospreys-Leicester, London Irish-Leinster (at Twickenham) and either Sale-Toulouse or Cardiff Blues-Harlequins promise a rare weekend of resolution. Normally, Munster have these last-round dramas to themselves, but this time they just take their place in the mix.

Part of the trouble is that three French giants have their pools more or less under their control already. Stade Français may have been rolled over by Ulster at Ravenhill, with Ian Humphreys having a game to remember, but they recovered the following week in Paris and should see off Bath this Saturday.

Toulouse lost away in Cardiff to the Blues, but look unbeatable at home and have lowly Harlequins there before that last encounter away in Stockport to Sale. For that final fixture to make the pulse race, Sale must first beat the Blues in a game that would stand apart in round five for dramatic potential, were it not that the Blues at the very worst moment are becalmed. Memories of their riotous progress to the semi-final last season have faded to such an extent that the only news out of their camp concerns Xavier Rush's possible departure to Japan and Ben Blair mulling offers from France.

Biarritz, still all over the shop in France's Top 14, are models of consistency in pool 2, unbeaten and eight points ahead of second-placed Gloucester. They could afford to lose at Kingsholm on Saturday and wrap up a quarter-final at one home, San Sebastián, with a victory at another, the Parc des Sports Aguiléra, over Glasgow.

The French control half the pools and it could have been worse for the other competing nations. Perpignan are the reigning domestic champions of France and Clermont the club they beat in last season's Top 14 final. But Perpignan came completely unstuck on the first weekend, losing away at Treviso, and then committed an even worse act in the eyes of their demanding supporters by losing at home to Munster. And not just losing, but being overwhelmed by the Irish province at their ominous best.

Munster, apparently recovered from the shock of seeing the balance of Irish power shift Leinster's way, are away in Treviso on Saturday lunchtime. The complacency that caused Perpignan to drop their guard in Italy will not touch Munster as long as they are only second-best in Ireland. In fact, there are few grounds to suppose that Ireland are going to be anything but ferocious in all competitions.

The good news for the health of the Heineken competition is that Northampton present a formidable challenge in Munster's pool. From the moment they refused to capitulate, away at the Stade Aimé-Giral on the one night that Perpignan gave it their all, Northampton seem to be striding forward on all fronts, no longer a dangerous side on their day, but consistently powerful and confident of their ability to play in a variety of styles. They have a chance to test the resolve of Perpignan, who might regret declaring their interest in the H Cup over.

Only one pool has a three-team contest for top spot, No3, involving Clermont, the Ospreys and Leicester. The French club still think they control the destiny of the group, thanks to the losing bonus point they picked up away at Leicester, and with "only" the Ospreys at home and Viadana away to come.

Now, the Ospreys, dare it be whispered after years of flopping on the big day, are playing with a ruthless steeliness. They are still without Mike Phillips but are grinding out important wins, rather than losing in glam-rock confusion. They have to take their new Magners form to the Stade Marcel-Michelin in Clermont-Ferrand, but they could produce the result of the weekend, even if it yields nothing more than a bonus point in defeat. On such fine margins will pool 3 be decided.

Talking of playing with steel, Leicester are as dynamic as any club in Europe at the moment, their demolition of Wasps a masterclass in taking a hold up front and never relaxing the grip. On the eve of the Six Nations and with England-Wales on the opening Saturday, the clash between the Ospreys and the Tigers at the Liberty Stadium in round six could not be a better prologue. It might be more uninhibited than the full Test. Leicester's home tie to Viadana in round five is not quite as tingling.

That leaves pool 6 where there is almost as much at stake in a strange Irish cross-border sort of way. London Irish, by support if not player registration, are still very much an Irish experience and Leinster are very much the team of the year in the age of the Irish. So, when London meets Dublin there's going to be a showdown.

But not yet. That's for round six and there are obstacles to climb first, London Irish, for example, at the Scarlets, who produced the shock of the tournament so far by beating the Exiles in Reading straight after the same Irish won away at Leinster.

As for the defending champions, they recovered from that opening shock by thumping first Brive and then the Scarlets on the road. Brive at home now should be a formality. As is the theme, it's a round to tick off before the real excitement comes the weekend after. The Irish and the Irish at Twickenham. Perfect.

Steve Borthwick might not join England in Six Nations

Steve Borthwick (Pic:Getty Images)

Martin Johnson last night put Steve Borthwick's future as England's Six Nations captain under threat.

The Saracens skipper has led his country in all 16 Test matches since Johnson became team manager two years ago.

And given the unwavering support shown to him by his boss despite only six wins in that time, Borthwick's reappointment was widely seen as a formality.

But at Twickenham yesterday Johnson hinted otherwise when he said: "We will name our captain as we get closer to the tournament.

"Steve's done a great job but everyone is competing for places. That's the way it has to be and the way Steve would want it." Johnson is under mounting pressure to lift England to a far higher level after another hugely disappointing autumn series.

Publicly he remains bullish, declaring: "We have a good enough group of players to go into any game in the Six Nations and think about winning it."

But privately the heat is on and he knows his captain must clearly merit selection ahead of young lock rival Courtney Lawes if he is to wear the armband. Borthwick's detractors argue he does not - and lacks the aura to inspire his men.

But his supporters, including rugby heavyweights Eddie Jones and Brendan Venter, vehemently disagree.

"I find it amazing people remotely think he's not good enough for England," Venter, Borthwick's club boss, has said. "If I had 15 Steve Borthwicks it would be amazing."

Johnson has long been of the same opinion but England are not improving and the clock is fast counting down to next year's World Cup. The question is whether Johnson, a naturally conservative selector, sticks by his experienced captain or bites the bullet and bloods a 20-year-old with immense potential but just one cap.

"Courtney came off the bench in one game for 10 minutes of international rugby," said Johnson, referring to Lawes' debut against Australia in November.

"He's improving all the time but is a young guy and we need to be mindful of that." Johnson has taken some big decisions - dropping Paul Sackey, a star of the last World Cup, for uncapped Northampton wing Chris Ashton.

He has also called up Shontayne Hape, Bath's former New Zealand rugby league star, with the view to him challenging another Kiwi-born centre, Riki Flutey, for the No.12 shirt.

But Hape's inclusion comes at the expense of the gifted Shane Geraghty - part of a supposed "golden generation" of young flair players, which includes Danny Cipriani and Ben Foden. Trouble is, England do not appear to rate any of them.

Three weeks on Saturday they open their Six Nations account against Wales at Twickenham. Win and anything will appear possible, in Six Nations terms anyway.

But lose and England will wonder where the next victory is coming from. Johnson needs to get his selection right. And he knows it.

ELITE 32-MAN SQUAD

England's squad for the Six Nations:

FORWARDS

S Armitage (London Irish)

S Borthwick (Saracens)

J Crane (Leicester)

T Croft (Leicester)

L Deacon (Leicester)

N Easter (Harlequins)

D Hartley (Northampton)

J Haskell (Stade Francais)

C Lawes (Northampton)